Bloomington Bagel Company Menu
Hand-Rolled Bagels Fresh Baked Daily
Signature Bagelwiches
-
Lotsa Lox
$11.99A hand-rolled bagel fresh baked daily, layered with schmear and premium nova lox. Finished with tomato, purple onion, capers, and a pickle spear. A Bloomington favorite for breakfast or lunch. Try it California style with our Sriracha Jalapeño schmear. Extra: 🥑🥔🧀
-
Wake and Bake
$8.75Perfect for breakfast in Bloomington. Egg, cheese, and schmear on a hand-rolled bagel fresh baked daily, topped with a crispy hash brown and your choice of two veggies. Got the munchies? This one's for you. Extra:🥑🧀🥔
-
Hangover
$10.99Our hearty cure-all for breakfast in Bloomington. Egg with your choice of cheese or schmear plus bacon, sausage, and ham on a hand-rolled bagel fresh baked daily. Includes two veggies to round it out. Self-medicating never tasted so good. Extra: 🥑🧀🥔
-
Hot Mess
$7.75Exactly what the name suggests. Egg, cheese, and one of our handcrafted schmears stacked on a hand-rolled bagel fresh baked daily. Served with two veggies and plenty of flavor. This should come with a bib—and a mimosa. Extra 🥑🧀🥔
-
Egg & Cheese
$5.80A classic breakfast in Bloomington. Egg and your choice of cheese or schmear on a warm hand-rolled bagel fresh baked daily. Add protein if you're extra hungry. Simple, satisfying, and delicious. Extra 🥑🧀🥔
-
Supernova
$12.99A loaded favorite featuring egg, cheese, schmear, nova lox, capers, tomato, and onion on a hand-rolled bagel fresh baked daily. Finished with a pickle spear. Everything you love, all in one bagelwich. Extra 🥑🧀🥔
-
Avocado Toast
4.62A hand-rolled bagel fresh baked daily, topped with smashed avocado and our signature Everyseed mix. A simple and satisfying vegetarian breakfast in Bloomington. Add protein for an extra boost.
-
Hummus-a-Tune
$10.99Creamy vegan hummus served on a warm hand-rolled bagel fresh baked daily with your choice of fresh veggies. A plant-based breakfast in Bloomington that doesn't compromise on flavor. Extra 🥑🧀🥔
-
Reuben
$8.99Hot turkey or corned beef served on a hand-rolled bagel fresh baked daily with melted Swiss, sauerkraut, and Thousand Island dressing. Choose your favorite veggies to finish it. A deli classic, reimagined on a bagel. 🥑🧀🥔
-
Veggie Bagelwich
$7.75Your choice of cheese or schmear on a hand-rolled bagel fresh baked daily, loaded with all the veggies your heart desires. A fresh, customizable breakfast in Bloomington for veggie lovers. Extra 🥑🧀🥔
-
Deli Bagelwich
$8.99Your choice of protein, cheese, and veggies served hot or cold on a hand-rolled bagel fresh baked daily. Build your perfect breakfast in Bloomington, your way. Extra 🥑🧀🥔
-
Willa's Choice
$4.98A comforting classic—smooth peanut butter with strawberry or grape jam on a warm hand-rolled bagel fresh baked daily. Simple, nostalgic, and delicious.
Fresh Baked Bagels
Our bagels are hand-rolled and fresh baked daily, giving them the perfect chewy texture inside and golden crust outside. Choose from classics like Plain, Everyseed, Onion, Sesame, Poppy, and Pretzel, or sweeter options like Blueberry, Cinnamon Raisin, and Cinnamon Sugar.
-
Bagels
$1.99 each or 17.99 DozenAvailable Varieties:
Plain, 11 Grain, Everyseed, Asiago (+$1.10), GF Plain (+$1.30), Onion, Pretzel, Sesame, Poppy, Cheddar Jalapeño, Blueberry, Cinnamon Raisin, Cinnamon Sugar< -
Schmears
$1.99 2ozSpread the flavor. Choose from classic cream cheese, veggie, chive, jalapeño sriracha, roasted red pepper, honey toasted almond, and many more—all perfect on a hand-rolled bagel fresh baked daily.
Available Varieties:
Plain, Plain Lite, Vegan Lite (+$1.59), Berry Lite, Veggie Lite, Spinach Lite, Chive, Smoked Nova Lox (+$0.76), Garlic & Herb, Hummus (Vegan), Jalapeño Sriracha, Brown Sugar Cinnamon, Honey Toasted Almond, Roasted Red Pepper, Artichoke Smoked Gouda, Scallion + Horseradish, Oreo, Butter
Also available: 8oz plain ($5.25) or 8oz flavored ($5.99) -
Veggies
$.75Add fresh veggie toppings to your hand-rolled bagel fresh baked daily. Choose from lettuce, spinach, tomato, capers, cucumbers, onions, jalapeños, black olives, green peppers, banana peppers, and sprouts. - Avocado +$1.50 - Hash Brown +$1.50
-
Proteins
Prices VaryBuild a hearty bagelwich with your favorite protein—perfect for a filling breakfast in Bloomington. Options: Fried Egg • Turkey • Bacon • Impossible Sausage • Spicy Sausage • Corned Beef • Ham • Veggie Burger • Lox • Tuna
-
Cheeses
1.50Melted cheese makes every bagelwich better. Choose from cheddar, pepper jack, Swiss, provolone, gouda, or muenster to pair with our hand-rolled bagels fresh baked daily.
-
Sauces
Add extra flavor to any bagelwich with our complimentary sauces: Ranch • Basil Pesto Aioli • Chipotle Ranch • Chili Oil • Ketchup • Sriracha • Mustard • Tabasco • Mayo
Sides & Extras
-
Fresh Fruit Cup
$3.99A refreshing side of assorted fruits cut fresh by hand. A light and healthy addition to your breakfast in Bloomington.
-
Fandango
$4.50Low-fat vanilla Greek yogurt topped with strawberries, mango, and blueberries, served with a side of granola for a sweet and satisfying start to the day.
-
Hash Brown(s)
$1.65-3.30Crispy air-fried hash browns—great on the side or added to your favorite hand-rolled bagel fresh baked daily. Ketchup and hot sauce available. Because it slaps.
-
Egg Bites
$3.85-$4.39Protein-packed egg bites available in three cheese (14g protein) or bacon (16g protein). A quick gluten-free option for breakfast in Bloomington.
Coffee & Espresso
-
Coffee
$2.99/3.25/3.50Locally roasted Baker's Blend or Hazelnut, brewed fresh and served hot or iced. The perfect pairing with a hand-rolled bagel fresh baked daily for breakfast in Bloomington.
-
Espresso
$2.50/2.75/3.25Rich espresso from locally roasted beans, crafted by Partridge & Quigley Coffee Company—our roasting partner since 1996.
-
Mocha or Chai
$4.50/4.99/5.50Warm and comforting drinks made with rich espresso or spiced chai. Choose 2% milk or oat milk (+$0.50) for a perfect pairing with our hand-rolled bagels fresh baked daily.
-
Cappuccinos or Lattes
$4.50/4.99/5.50Smooth espresso drinks crafted with steamed milk and topped with light foam. Choose 2% milk or oat milk (+$0.50) to enjoy alongside your breakfast in Bloomington.
-
Add a flavored syrup
$.75Customize your drink with a splash of flavor: Vanilla • Hazelnut • Caramel • Butterscotch • Toasted Marshmallow • Lavender • Raspberry • Strawberry • Blueberry
Specialty Drinks
-
Iced S'mores Latte
$5.50A sweet and indulgent iced latte made with locally roasted espresso, your choice of milk (2% or oat +$0.50), Ghirardelli chocolate, and toasted marshmallow syrup. Finished with whipped cream, mini chocolate chips, and graham cracker crumbs. Perfect alongside a hand-rolled bagel fresh baked daily.
-
Iced Caramel Butterscotch Latte
$5.50Smooth espresso blended with your favorite milk (2% or oat +$0.50), caramel syrup, and rich butterscotch sauce. Topped with whipped cream and mini butterscotch chips for a decadent treat.
Fresh Baked Treats
Smoothies
-
Strawberry Banana, Blueberry, Tropical Green
$6.25Refreshing smoothies blended with real fruit for a lighter option alongside breakfast in Bloomington. Choose 2% milk or oat milk (+$0.50), add whey protein (+$1.99), or top with whipped cream. Vegan options available with mix-ins like chia, flax, and hemp.
-
Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup Protein
$6.25A rich protein smoothie blended with chocolate whey protein and peanut butter flavor. A satisfying drink to enjoy with our hand-rolled bagels fresh baked daily.
-
Detox Smoothie
$7.99A refreshing blend of banana, mango, strawberry, ginger, and coconut water designed to help you recharge. Lagging a bit after a night at the Upstairs? This will sort your brain and body. A bright and energizing choice when you're grabbing breakfast in Bloomington.
Beverages
FAQ
Are your bagels really fresh baked daily?
What makes your bagels different?
Our bagels are hand-rolled using traditional methods and fresh baked daily—not mass-produced or shipped in frozen. This gives them the perfect chewy texture inside with a golden, slightly crispy outside that bagel lovers in Bloomington have enjoyed since 1996.
Do you have vegan or gluten-free options?
Can I order bagels for catering or events?
Yes! We offer catering for meetings, events, and gatherings. Contact any of our three Bloomington locations to place a catering order for hand-rolled bagels fresh baked daily, plus schmears, breakfast sandwiches, and more.
Can I order bagels for catering or events?
Yes! We offer catering for meetings, events, and gatherings. Contact any of our three Bloomington locations to place a catering order for hand-rolled bagels fresh baked daily, plus schmears, breakfast sandwiches, and more.
What are your most popular breakfast items?
Do you have breakfast all day?
Where are your Bloomington locations?
We have three convenient locations in Bloomington:
– Downtown: 238 N Morton St (near campus)
– North Dunn St: 113 N Dunn St
– College Mall: 913 S College Mall Rd
Stop by the location nearest you for fresh baked bagels and breakfast in Bloomington!
Can I order online?
Yes! Visit our website or call your nearest location to place an order for pickup. Perfect for busy mornings when you need breakfast in Bloomington on the go.
Visit Us Today
Craving a hand-rolled bagel fresh baked daily? Stop by any of our three Bloomington locations for the best bagels and breakfast in Bloomington. Get directions, call ahead, or order online! **Downtown:** 238 N Morton St | **North Dunn:** 113 N Dunn St | **College Mall:** 913 S College Mall Rd